Inquiry Basket
Many PCR reactions fail due to issues with the synthetic oligonucleotide primers used rather than due to experimental technique or equipment failure. Sometimes even when one has optimized all of the reaction parameters and cycling conditions, the reaction may fail due to small chemical or structural defects in the primer sequence that prevent efficient DNA synthesis by Taq polymerase. When something goes wrong with a PCR reaction there can be no production of product, slow yield of product or non-specific amplification of sequences other than the target sequence. It helps to know what sorts of weaknesses synthetic oligonucleotides have so that one can figure out what has gone wrong and how to fix it to let the PCR reaction go to completion. Possible weaknesses with synthetic primers include poor primer design, chemical degradation, and impurities from synthesis.
The PCR reaction is dependent on short strands of nucleotides called primers to start the reaction. Therefore if a reaction does not work, most molecular biologists think that the problem is with the DNA template or the polymerase rather than thinking about whether the primers could be faulty. Primer faults can arise due to poor manufacturing or handling of the primers. Errors can occur in the synthesized primer sequence or the primer could be chemically modified or degraded during synthesis or storage. Poor primer design can also cause problems with reactions by creating secondary structures that hide the ends of the primer. By thinking the problem lies with something other than the primer, people usually try to troubleshoot other variables in the reaction.
Primer design strategy for AELA PCR.1,5
Several other primer-specific issues that are often overlooked during PCR troubleshooting include ones that dramatically affect the outcome of your reaction. Oxidation or hydrolysis of primers as well as freeze/thaw degradation lowers the effective concentration of your primers over time. This will result in slowly decreasing amounts of your product being made over several experiments instead of suddenly failing to produce any product. Lack of purity of primers due to synthesis artifacts such as shortened primers or uncleaved protecting groups will compete with your intended primer for binding to the template but will not be extended by polymerase, lowering the effective concentration of your primer. When these primers bind to each other (primer dimers) or to themselves (hairpins), the 3'OH that is necessary for extension by polymerase is blocked.
| Issue Category | Mechanism | Experimental Manifestation | Diagnostic Indicator |
| Chemical degradation | Hydrolysis, oxidation, photobleaching | Reduced amplification efficiency over time | Drifting cycle thresholds |
| Synthesis impurities | Truncated sequences, deprotection failures | Competition for template binding | Higher than expected primer concentrations required |
| Secondary structure | Hairpin formation, primer dimers | Blocked extension, nonspecific products | Low molecular weight bands on gel analysis |
| Design deficiencies | Suboptimal melting temperature, self-complementarity | Poor specificity, inefficient annealing | Multiple product bands or smearing |
Table 1 Common Primer-Related Causes of PCR Failure
Poor primer design is one cause of PCR failure that is encoded in the thermodynamic and structural properties of the primers themselves. Failures due to bad design are distinct from failures that occur due to faulty storage or synthesis of the primers over time. Factors that lead to poor primer design include Tm that is too low or too high, too much GC content, and/or secondary structures that will compete with template binding. If PCR fails due to poor primer design, the primers will fail to bind to the template even if everything is perfect and the reagents haven't degraded, therefore the primer sequences will have to be redesigned.
Typical primer length and melting temperature are related properties. Primer size should be at least 18 bases to adequately discriminate its target from unrelated sequences. However, primers longer than necessary encourage the formation of hairpin structures that hide their ends from reaction with their target sequence. Likewise, if the melting temperature is too low, the primer will not bind strongly to the template. If it is too high, higher reaction temperatures will be required for primer annealing which decreases enzyme activity. Ideally the melting temperatures should be similar between the forward and reverse primers to ensure that both will bind at the same time. If there is a large difference in melting temperature between primers, the primer with the lower melting temperature will tend to dominate the reaction. Lower yields of product and higher quantities of single-stranded DNA may occur.
A critical parameter in primer design is the GC-content of the primer. If the GC-content is too low, the resulting primer pair will have poor melting temperature and binding efficiency. Additionally, low GC-content may result in mispriming to sequences that are not the desired target. High GC-content can cause primers to bind to each other instead of to the template DNA. High GC-content can also lead to the formation of secondary structures within the primer if there are regions that are G-rich and can bind to themselves. Sequences that are rich in homopolymers, or simple repeats, also have a tendency to form secondary structures or bind non-specifically to other sequences. Simple sequences, especially those that are AT-rich or GC-rich, tend to not map uniquely to the genome and can bind to multiple sites creating unwanted byproducts or secondary structures.
Hairpinning and self-dimerization are an often overlooked parameter that can critically invalidate primers due to sequestering of ends. When regions inside a primer are complementary to each other, it can cause stem-loop structures ('hairpins') that will sterically hinder the three prime end. When forward and reverse primers bind to each other ('self-dimerize'), especially if there is complementarity at the three prime end, it ties up reagents without generating the amplicon of interest. Secondary structure should be checked when designing primers with a thermodynamic calculator. If a primer is found to create stable hairpins or self-dimers, those regions should be mutated out if possible. It is difficult to change reaction conditions to prevent stable secondary structures from forming.
Structural self-contamination of primers is another reason for PCR failure. Self-contamination occurs when there is intramolecular base pairing within a primer sequence or intermolecular base pairing between primer sequences. These structures reduce primer availability by hiding the reactive ends necessary for binding to the template sequence. Structural problems are independent of storage time or proper storage of primers. A primer will adopt these structures because they are encoded in its sequence. Structural problems include hairpins (structures formed by intramolecular basepairing within a primer), self-dimers (structures formed by intermolecular basepairing between two primers of the same sequence), and cross-dimers (structures formed by intermolecular basepairing between two different primers). All three structural problems hide the 3'OH group of the primer. Structural problems create very stable structures that cannot be used by DNA polymerase to extend a daughter strand. Structural stability can sometimes be stronger than the primer-template interaction itself.
Detection of PCR products in qPCR using TaqMan probes (a-c) or Plexor technology (d-f).2,5
Hairpins will occur when there are sequences towards the interior of a primer that are self-complementary. A hairpin structure consists of a stem loop structure where the end of the primer is tucked into the stem. Hairpins will occur frequently in GC-rich areas or inverted repeats of the primer sequence. They are stable based on the number of bases in the stem. Self-dimers are formed when primers have ends or internal sequences that are palindromic in nature. These primer-primer dimers anneal head-to-head/tail-to-tail consuming reagents with no product formation. The most detrimental structure is the cross-dimer. Cross-dimers form when the forward primer and reverse primer are complementary, usually at the 3'-end. Each primer can extend the other during PCR, resulting in small primer-dimers that outcompete the desired reaction for reagents. Tertiary structure interactions at the 3'-end can inhibit extension altogether, even if the interaction is not very stable.
Synthesis by solid-phase oligonucleotide synthesis, even with near perfect efficiency at each step will result in a mixture of full-length primer and shorter failure sequences. Impurities due to synthesis failure accumulate at each step of the chain growth as each coupling reaction is typically less than 100% efficient. Primer sequences truncated at any point during synthesis will act as competitors to primer-template binding as well as polymerase association, diminishing the effective concentration of reagent available for amplification. In contrast to sequence-related problems which are predictable from the sequence itself, synthesis problems are fabrication errors that are unpredictable and may differ from lot to lot or between manufacturers.
Incomplete reaction (coupling efficiency) at each step of solid-phase synthesis (usually 98-99.5%, depending on sequence and scale) results in significant quantities of truncated failure sequences ('minus-ones', 'minus-twos', etc.). Although complementary to template, they compete with the desired product for template binding but are not extended by polymerase because they lack the complete 3' end of the primer. Failure to purify away these truncated primers can significantly impact experiments. Truncated primers are often present after desalting purifications typically used for research-use-only primers. High-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) purification is necessary to remove these truncated failure sequences.
Stability of synthesized primers during storage and use is an often overlooked source of PCR fidelity. Degradation is cumulative over time and results from hydrolytic, oxidative, and photochemical damage to primers. Conditions under which oligonucleotides are stored and handled (temperature, exposure to light, freeze-thaw cycles) can greatly impact shelf life as well as introduce additional stressors beyond those innate to nucleic acids. Storage-associated damage is frequently unrecognized as the DNA is intact, yet there may be enough damaged primer to affect reactions.
Chemical instability results from gradual acid hydrolysis of the phosphodiester backbone, oxidation of bases, and deamination of purines. The pH-sensitive phosphodiester backbone may be hydrolyzed under acidic conditions, or when frozen then thawed if stored in non-buffered conditions (freezing/thawing concentrated oligos will acidify). Hydrolysis cleaves the oligo into useless smaller fragments. Reactive oxygen species attack the bases, again producing unusable oligos that polymerases cannot extend. Deamination of purines will create apurinic sites, decreasing the melting temperature of oligonucleotide primers. Freeze/thaw cycling can contribute to chemical instability by shearing oligos. Every freeze also concentrates oligos and introduces new oxygen and potential nucleases to a primer.
Primer stability is also affected by environmental conditions experienced during regular laboratory use. Light, humidity and oxygen can lead to photochemical and oxidative degradation. Direct photolysis of nucleobases by UV or visible radiation can occur, and fluorescent labels may also produce reactive species upon light absorption that can damage neighboring bases. Oxygen in the air can react to form oxidative byproducts, preferentially damaging guanine. Humidity can promote hydrolysis, and additionally promotes growth of contaminating organisms that can produce nucleases. Damage from these sources can be limited by storing primers in dark or amber-colored bottles, under dried-down conditions, or under an inert atmosphere. Antioxidant buffers can also be employed. Use of aliquots, whereby multiple smaller working stocks are created from one larger stock primer solution, can limit exposure to degrading conditions by reducing the number of times the original stock needs to be accessed.
| Factor | Degradative Mechanism | Increased water activity, enhanced degradation | Impact on PCR |
| Repeated freeze-thaw | Mechanical stress, solute concentration | Aliquoting into single-use volumes | Gradual yield reduction, increasing variability |
| Light exposure | Photochemical damage, oxidation | Amber storage containers, minimized light exposure | Reduced amplification efficiency |
| Acidic pH | Hydrolysis of phosphodiester bonds | Neutral pH buffers (pH 7.0-8.0) | Truncated primers, failed extension |
| Oxidative conditions | Base modification, strand breaks | Antioxidants, inert atmosphere, chelating agents | Modified primers, mispriming |
| High dilution | Increased water activity, enhanced degradation | Concentrated stocks (100 μM or higher) | Accelerated degradation kinetics |
Table 2 Storage Factors Affecting Primer Stability
Effects of primer problems are often visible during PCR. For example, primer problems often lead to poor specificity and efficiency when amplifying your target of interest. These problems can occur because you have less effective primer available for the reaction. They can also occur because your primer may not hybridize as well as it should or because there are competing products being amplified during the reaction. By knowing PCR problems that can occur because of primer issues, you can often identify the issue you are having and fix it. Primer problems can be one of many things such as chemical damage to the primer, impurities introduced during synthesis, or poor primer design. Each of these issues can create different effects observable by your amplification plot, gel image, or melting curve.
The two most common results of primer failure are non-specific amplification (indicated by more than one band or smear on a gel) or low PCR yield (visualized as no band or a faint band despite using enough template DNA). When a primer begins to fail, it often binds less specifically, causing it to amplify non-target sequences (if there are sequences that it partially binds to elsewhere in the genome) or form primer-dimers with the other primer(s) in the reaction. Any time these reactions occur, they lower the effective concentration of both reactants and polymerase for the desired PCR reaction. The other common issue when primers fail is that there is not enough primer available to get a good yield. This can happen if the primer degrades, if there was product contamination when the primer was made, or if the primer is sequestered into secondary structures. In cases where this occurs, there might not be enough active primer to reach the critical concentration needed to observe amplification with low-copy or difficult templates.
Failure of primers during qPCR reactions lead to false negatives. Poor quality primers due to degradation or contamination will lead to higher Ct values causing an underestimation of the amount of target present. Inconsistent quality of primer batches can lead to faulty standard curves which can cause inconsistencies when comparing experiments. False positives can occur if there is nonspecific amplification of DNA. During some clinical diagnostic tests, a false positive will lead to unnecessary treatments. Since poor quality primers can go bad over time, it can cause a slow change that may go unnoticed over the course of many experiments. The change in expression (or virus levels) may be blamed on other factors. Therefore it is important to ensure that your primers are working efficiently by looking at standard curves and melt curves.
Attempts to remedy primer problems by tweaking PCR conditions often fail, or may make matters worse. Using higher primer concentrations can help to salvage damaged or impure primers, but will likely increase primer-dimer formation and nonspecific amplification. Modifying annealing temperatures can mitigate poor melting behavior, but will likely decrease specificity (or specificity but increase efficiency). Extension time cannot solve problems with missing 3' ends. It's generally best to fix primer problems by redesigning, repurifying, or replacing the primer instead of trying to adjust the reaction to work around the problem.
Troubleshooting primer problems before PCR reactions can save time and effort. Factors such as primer design, quality and storage all play important roles in decreasing non-specific reactions. First, choose your primers wisely. Utilize software to check that all your template parameters are correct. Make sure that there are no hairpins, dimers or other things that could inhibit your reaction. Also, determine what grade of primer you would like to use. If you are doing a quick QC experiment, perfectly pristine primers may not be necessary. However, if you are running your mysticatest ever, you may want to invest in higher quality primers. Finally, store your primers properly before use. PCR chemicals can degrade over time if exposed to drastic temperature changes. So try to store your primers at a consistent temperature. By taking these steps before you start your PCR reactions, you can decrease the amount of variation in your experiments and avoid having to repeat failed experiments.
Choosing primers based on thermodynamic properties, specificity, and predicted secondary structure will help lead you to sequences best suited for amplification. Tm values can be calculated from the nearest-neighbor method and should be comparable between your forward and reverse primers. Aim for 40-60% GC content in your primers. Use an alignment tool to make sure your primers are not targeting similar regions elsewhere in your genome. Calculate potential secondary structures of your primers using a calculator. These structures include hairpins and self-dimers. If the free energy of these structures is too high, your primers will not be single stranded enough to bind to your template. Decide on your primers before ordering them. If the parameters described above don't fall within accepted ranges, go back and redesign your primers.
Choosing the right primer grade purity and quality suppliers will help you achieve successful PCR outcomes for many applications. DESALTED primers that are made for research use are acceptable for many standard screening and qualitative applications. HIGH PERFORMANCE LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY or polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis purified primers (which remove shorter truncated pieces and leftover chemical building blocks from synthesis) are often desired for quantitative PCR, cloning, and diagnostic applications. Quality suppliers should be able to provide information about their quality controls such as quality management systems they have in place and batch-to-batch consistency. It is also important that they have knowledgeable technical support to help you should you encounter problems and need to request new synthesizing. Choosing primers of a lower grade or from cheaper suppliers can seem like an inexpensive option but is often not when you have to repeat failed experiments or are trying to publish data.
| Prevention Category | Specific Strategy | Implementation | Expected Benefit |
| Design optimization | Computational thermodynamic and structural analysis | Pre-synthesis in silico evaluation | Elimination of structurally defective sequences |
| Quality selection | Appropriate purification grade matching application sensitivity | HPLC or PAGE for quantitative/diagnostic applications | Removal of synthesis impurities and truncation products |
| Supplier qualification | Assessment of quality systems and consistency | Selection of reputable providers with documented processes | Batch-to-batch reproducibility |
| Storage management | Aliquoting, temperature control, light protection | Single-use aliquots, freezer storage, opaque containers | Preservation of chemical integrity |
| Quality monitoring | Periodic performance validation | Control amplification with reference standards | Early detection of degradation |
Table 3 Preventive Strategies for Primer-Related PCR Failures
Primer-related PCR failure is often linked to sequence inaccuracies, truncated products, suboptimal purification, or batch inconsistency. Even well-designed primers can underperform if synthesis quality is not carefully controlled. Our primer synthesis capabilities are aligned with the technical demands of PCR and qPCR applications:
By aligning primer design considerations with controlled synthesis and purification strategies, common oligonucleotide-related PCR issues can often be significantly reduced.
If your PCR experiments consistently show low yield, non-specific amplification, primer dimer formation, or unstable quantification results, it may be beneficial to reassess primer design and synthesis quality.
Careful evaluation of primer sequence, purification level, and quality control parameters can prevent repeated troubleshooting and improve amplification reliability. Contact our scientific team to discuss your PCR primer requirements and determine the most appropriate synthesis and purification strategy for your application.
References
